This news has been received from: Associated Press

All trademarks, copyrights, videos, photos and logos are owned by respective news sources. News stories, videos and live streams are from trusted sources.

BOSTON (AP) — A panel of appeals court judges on Wednesday repeatedly challenged the legal claims of a group that accuses Harvard University of intentional discrimination against Asian American students who apply to the Ivy League school.

The three-judge panel of the 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Boston appeared skeptical of arguments made by Students for Fair Admissions, which says Harvard imposes a “racial penalty” on Asian Americans.

When a lawyer for the group accused the school of racial stereotyping against Asian American applicants, a judge interrupted and questioned the basis of the claim.

“Where is the evidence of racial profiling here?” Judge Juan Torruella asked.

The panel is expected to make a decision on the case in coming weeks. Either way, legal experts believe the case will probably end up before the Supreme Court.

Students for Fair Admissions is asking the appeals court to overturn a trial-level judge’s 2019 decision finding that Harvard does not intentionally discriminate against Asian Americans. U.S. District Judge Allison D. Burroughs issued the decision in October after a three-week trial.

In her ruling, Burroughs said Harvard’s admissions process is “not perfect” but concluded that there was “no evidence of any racial animus whatsoever.” She ruled that other factors beyond bias could explain why Harvard accepts Asian American students at lower rates than students of other races.

The group’s lawsuit alleges that Harvard admissions officers use a subjective “personal rating” assigned to each student to discriminate against Asian Americans. Using six years of admissions data, the group found that Asian American applicants averaged the highest scores in an academic rating but received the lowest personal ratings, and that they were admitted at lower rates.

Harvard denies any bias and defends its use of race in the application process. The school says race is one of many factors considered and that at most it provides a “tip” in favor of underrepresented students. It says the university has a “compelling interest” in attracting a diverse student body to its campus.

Presenting the case to judges, a lawyer for the group said Harvard’s practices go beyond the limited consideration of race that has been upheld by the Supreme Court. Attorney William Consovoy said the school’s efforts to keep a similar racial makeup among students from year to year amounts to illegal racial balancing.

“The statistical evidence in this case showed that the personal rating discriminates against Asian Americans in a statistically significant way,” Consovoy said.

But Judge Sandra L. Lynch challenged that allegation, saying that, presented with competing statistical models from both sides, the trial court judge sided with Harvard’s.

“The district court actually found that Harvard’s statistical model was the more reliable one,” Lynch said. “So, again, I’m just trying to get your argument.” Consovoy argued that both models were deemed credible.

A representative for the U.S. Justice Department spoke in support of Students for Fair Admissions on Wednesday, arguing that race “pervades every aspect” of Harvard’s admissions process. Eric S. Dreiband, assistant attorney general for the Civil Rights Division, said the school’s admissions process “unduly burdens” Asian American applicants compared to white applicants.

The Trump administration has opposed the use of race at Harvard and other colleges across the U.S. Last month, the Justice Department found that Yale University discriminates against Asian American and white applicants. The finding, which resulted from a two-year inquiry, was rejected by Yale as “meritless” and “hasty.”

As evidence, the group points to a U.S. Education Department investigation into Harvard’s admissions practices in the 1990s. In that case, the agency also explored whether Harvard discriminates against Asian Americans. The school was ultimately cleared.

Speaking on behalf of the university Wednesday, attorney Seth Waxman said the school’s personal rating, which was also examined during the federal inquiry, has “assumed a Frankenstein-like significance.” But he argued that the 1990s investigation only helps Harvard’s case.

“It reached the exact same conclusion, based on its review of all the evidence, that Judge Burroughs did,” he said.

News Source: Associated Press

Tags: against asian americans against asian american personal rating s admissions the school s

LEADING OFF: Cubs Mills back on mound after no-hitter

Next News:

Opinion: As the SEC pushed through with patience, the Big Ten faltered in its handling of COVID-19

Songs we’d love to hear Beyoncé cover 7 Reasons Not to Move When You Retire Opinion: As the SEC pushed through with patience, the Big Ten faltered in its handling of COVID-19

The stress was unrelenting, and Greg Sankey’s head pounded.

Why the Big Tens return needed to happen to legitimize CFP and 2020 champion USA TODAY SPORTS See more videos SHARE SHARE TWEET SHARE EMAIL What to watch next
  • Bakersfield College breaking racial barriers in the athletics department

    KERO Bakersfield, CA
  • Lorenzen Wright’s family is still waiting for justice: Part 11

    ABC News
  • Protesters call for Rootstown superintendents resignation after football coach leaves

    WKYC-TV Cleveland
  • Fire Fight Against Bobcat Fire Continues In Angeles National Forest

    CBS Los Angeles
  • Highlights and interviews from Vero Beach’s win against Port St. Lucie

    The St. Lucie News-Tribune
  • Shower Power helping feed the homeless

    WAPT Jackson
  • Fire chief honored at Lovelands homecoming game against Little Miami

    WLWT Cincinnati
  • Rootstown Friday night football game met with protest over racial slur incident

    WEWS Cleveland, OH
  • Indiana High School Football Highlights: Center Grove 47, North Central 0

    Indianapolis Star
  • Indiana High School Football Highlights: Carmel 36, Lawrence North 34

    Indianapolis Star
  • Indiana High School Football Highlights: Cathedral 25, St. Xavier (Ohio) 22

    Indianapolis Star
  • West Bloomfield (MI) RB Donovan Edwards reacts to big win over Oak Park

    SMG
  • HS GameTime: Meet Nathan McEIroy Trinity quarterback

    WHAS-TV Louisville
  • WATCH: Anderson football players - Were finally living up the potential

    Cincinnati Enquirer
  • Trinity coaches, players remember Steven Tompkins

    WHAS-TV Louisville
  • Texas A&M gives preview of game day safety at Kyle Field

    KAGS-TV Waco-Temple-Bryan
Click to expand Replay Video
  • Bakersfield College breaking racial barriers in the athletics department Bakersfield College breaking racial barriers in the athletics department KERO Bakersfield, CA
  • Lorenzen Wright’s family is still waiting for justice: Part 11 The trial for Billy Ray Turner, charged in Wright’s murder, is scheduled for this fall but it’s unlikely it will happen due to COVID-19 precautions. He has pleaded not guilty. ABC News
  • Protesters call for Rootstown superintendents resignation after football coach leaves Coach Troy Spiker resigned last week after Superintendent Andrew Hawkins overturned his discipline of a player. The student had allegedly used racial slurs. WKYC-TV Cleveland
UP NEXT

College football’s landscape was changing at a dizzying pace before the SEC commissioner’s eyes. The 2020 season now hung in the balance and the pressure from all sides began to mount.

First, the Big Ten moved to a conference-only schedule in early July, which blindsided many of the sport’s power brokers. Then, on Aug. 11, the league elected to postpone fall sports indefinitely and focus on playing football at some point in 2021. Soon thereafter, the Pac-12 announced its own shutdown, riding the wave of cancellations that detonated schedules.

Start the day smarter. Get all the news you need in your inbox each morning.

Sankey reached for not one Aleve PM, but two.

With blood rushing to his head, he tried to remain as calm and deliberate as he had been ever since March, when his job became an exercise in crisis management with the onset ofa global pandemic. As Sankey recalled that hectic period Tuesday on the eve of the Big Ten’s decision to reinstate its football season for the Oct. 23-24 weekend, he did so comfortably reassured about choices he made.

© Junfu Han, Detroit Free Press Michigan football head coach Jim Harbaugh, holding the hand of his daughter Addie, marches with players, their parents and supporters outside Michigan Stadium in Ann Arbor, to protest the postponement of the fall football season on Sept. 5, 2020.

Finding a way to play was central to Sankey’s thinking as he contemplated what the absence of a season would mean for the student-athletes he governed.

“That was their time,” he said. “So part of my personal thinking was the responsibility was to provide that opportunity — not that I can guarantee it. In fact, I very much cannot guarantee anything in this environment. I am open and honest about that reality. But I had the responsibility to try because it’s now somebody else’s time this year.”

Other News

  • Saturday Night Owls: The coronavirus pandemic is widening the racial wealth gap
  • Gabriella Abutbol Posts Steamy Bikini Update And Niece Waidhofers Comment Slays Fans
  • Protests Against Police Brutality, For Racial Justice Held Around Chicago; Near West Protest Turns Combative
  • Joe Biden Should Nominate Michelle Obama To The Supreme Court, Columnist Says
  • Ruth Bader Ginsburgs classmate recalls their parallel paths
  • Oakland Catholic Diocese launches racial justice task force after shocking accusation against bishop
  • Roe v. Wade could be overturned after Ruth Bader Ginsburgs death
  • Daisey ODonnell Poses On Her Knees Wearing Skimpy Bathing Suit And Mentions A Predatory Animal
  • A True Hero: Ruth Bader Ginsburgs Alma Maters Mourn Her Death
  • Gauahar Khan Is All Things Sweet and Graceful in a Floral Ethnic Suit!
  • Princeton Professor Blames Bomb Threats on Trump Administrations Racial Bias Investigation
  • Two Female Appeals Court Judges on Trump's List for Supreme Court Nominees - Source
  • Cities Creating Racial 'Healing' Committees to Confront Past
  • Racial justice uprisings bring renewed calls for diversity and inclusion in ballet
  • Cities creating racial ‘healing’ committees to confront past
  • Cities creating racial healing committees to confront past
  • Manager Ordered US Census Layoffs Despite Judges Ruling
  • Inside Conor McGregor’s own fashion range with tailor David August – the man who designed the infamous ‘F*** You’ suit
  • Renowned Harvard trauma expert: There’s a ‘very real threat of a racist, misogynist and deadly dystopia’ if Trump wins in November